Hi Rose,
1/ I have activated as indicated
2/ I have checked setting and they are the same
3/ Currently no white or black list active. Only limit loging attemp to 60 try then lockout for 10 min. I have also tried deactivating it but no difference.
4/ Already tested this step with xstore theme + xstore core + woocommerce only active and same issue. In addition to it to check if there is a problem with wordpress installation I have tested using theme Twenty Twenty-OneVersion: 1.8 + woocommerce + miniorange social-login. In this test social login was working but miniorange not compatible with xstore.
I haven’t check other social plugin as most of them require payment and not sure if compatible with xstore
🙁