Dear @nebcreative,
If you want to have pages instead of a load more, go to Plugins and disable WooCommerce Infinite Scroll and Ajax Pagination plugin. This plugin is recommended but is not required.
If You need to have Infinite Scroll or Ajax Pagination, go to Settings > WooCommerce Infinite Scroll and set Global Settings, Selector Settings and Advanced Settings according to your theme version as described in our documentation. I’ve checked your settings and they are incorrect, so it is the reason for your problem.
Regards